Lesson 3: The Cistercian Movement and Its Expansion
“The new birth took place… and was in origin the work of individual reformers…” “They were the preachers, the writers and the schoolmasters of their age…” “As historians, as theologians, as biblical commentators… they were supreme until 1100 and still notable in 1150" The Benedictine Centuries: THE MONASTIC CONQUEST, p. 54, 55, 60.
1. Preference for Remote and Undeveloped Land
Teaching: The Cistercians deliberately chose remote, undeveloped lands instead of fertile or populated areas.
Key Idea:
The author shows that Cistercians saw working harsh, untouched land as part of their spiritual discipline and commitment to simplicity and independence.
Key Takeaway:
Purposeful hardship can be used as a tool for discipline and identity.
2. Appeal of the Cistercian Ideal
Teaching: The Cistercian model attracted followers because of its simplicity, structure, and strong sense of purpose.
Key Idea:
The author explains that in a world already full of monasteries, the strict but practical lifestyle of the Cistercians appealed to both elites and individuals seeking meaningful, active religious lives.
Key Takeaway:
Clear purpose and strong identity attract committed followers.
3. Criticism and Consequences of Success
Teaching: As the Cistercians grew wealthier, they faced increasing criticism and internal challenges.
Key Idea:
The author highlights that the order’s success led to accusations of greed and harsh treatment of the poor, showing how growth can undermine original ideals.
Key Takeaway:
Success can create the very problems a movement originally tried to escape.
4. Economic Transformation Through Agriculture
Teaching: The Cistercians transformed unused land into productive agricultural and economic centers.
Key Idea:
The author illustrates that through the use of lay-brothers and organized labor, the Cistercians turned wastelands into thriving estates that contributed significantly to regional economies.
Key Takeaway:
Organization and labor can transform even the most unproductive environments.
5. Spiritual Appeal and Recruitment
Teaching: Cistercian leaders, especially figures like Bernard of Clairvaux, inspired followers through vivid spiritual messaging.
Key Idea:
The author shows that emotional and symbolic appeals—promising peace, unity, and spiritual fulfillment—played a powerful role in drawing people into the monastic life.
Key Takeaway:
Strong messaging and vision are essential for inspiring commitment.
Five Memorable Facts
-
Cistercians chose remote, difficult land on purpose for spiritual discipline.
-
They turned wastelands into productive farms and economic centers.
-
Their movement quickly attracted large numbers of followers.
-
Success led to criticism, wealth, and loss of early simplicity.
-
Leaders like Bernard inspired people with powerful spiritual promises of peace and purpose.
Applicable Reflections
Spiritual Application:
-
Choose challenging environments to grow: Just like the Cistercians chose difficult land, putting yourself in harder situations (academically or personally) can build discipline and resilience.
-
Stay grounded during success: The Cistercians were criticized after becoming wealthy, showing the importance of staying true to your original values even when you succeed.
-
Turn disadvantages into strengths: They transformed wasteland into productive farms—apply this by using limited resources creatively to succeed.
-
Use clear purpose to attract opportunities: Their strong identity drew many followers, so clearly defining your goals can help attract the right people and opportunities in your life.
-
Combine hard work with smart organization: The success of their agricultural system shows that effort alone isn’t enough—structure and planning make effort effective.
What does Knowles have to say?
“But for a moment, a space of fifty years, monasticism seemed to have conquered the western church. In the dark ages, when the secular clergy and the bishops were very generally appointed and controlled by emperors, kings, magnates and landowners the monks had gradually gained a monopoly of learning and fervour. They had elaborated the liturgy and multiplied manuscripts of the fathers and spiritual writers, as well as of the poets and historians of Rome. When the great reform movement got under way it was mainly steered by monks, who gave as a nostrum for all spiritual ills the monastic virtues and devotions – chastity, obedience and the liturgy… Thus the whole church was monachised in various degrees.”
The Benedictine Centuries: THE MONASTIC CONQUEST, p. 83.